Evidence-Based Analysis of the “Anti-Transgender Extremism” Guide (2024): Briefing for Clinicians & Educators

​

This is an evidence-based analysis, not a position paper on gender identity or trans rights.

​

• It assesses whether specific claims meet professional standards for risk assessment.

• It asserts professionals must distinguish between political disagreement and actual threats to safety.

• It acknowledges that trans people can face genuine discrimination and safety concerns. However distinguishing legitimate concern from actual extremism is why evidence-based assessment matters.

​​

WHY THIS MATTERS:

Schools, health services, youth workers, and mental-health practitioners are increasingly encountering materials that label certain viewpoints as “extremist” or “violent.” It is critical that front-line professionals can distinguish actual risks of harm from politicised framing, in order to uphold duty of care, child safeguarding, and evidence-based practice.

​

The Gender Minorities Aotearoa booklet 'Anti-Transgender Extremism' (2024) is one such document. It is funded under New Zealand’s Preventing and Countering Violent Extremism Fund and is already used to brief venues, service providers, councils, and community workers.

​

This briefing provides a professional, evidence-based analysis of its claims.